new backdrop settings dialog

Brian J. Tarricone bjt23 at cornell.edu
Sat Feb 14 22:41:41 CET 2004


Nikola Pizurica wrote:

>It's nice, but why not recreating (or modifying) "Desktop Wallpaper
>Preferences" from Gnome 2.5, I find it very nice:
>http://nothome.com/fedora-1.90.png
>  
>
i had been thinking about that one, actually, and while i think that 
dialog _looks nice_, i personally don't think it's terribly functional 
or flexible:

1) it forces the user to work with a list-type model, when maybe all 
they want to do is set their backdrop to a photo they just took.
2) it makes adding other options (a true image list, a random image) 
result in adding UI elements that make it look like an afterthought.
3) if someone comes up with a new option for displaying the backdrop, it 
will likely require an UI redesign, where with my design, it can likely 
just be added as an extra option.

and then there's the egotisical argument... why would we want a backdrop 
settings box that's just a clone of gnome's? ^_~   seriously, though, i 
have no problem with borrowing ideas from elsewhere... as long as i 
think they are good ideas.

now, i have a problem with the dialog i came up with, that i'm not sure 
how to solve.  if there is an image selected for the backdrop, but it 
doesn't fill the entire screen, then the currently selected color should 
fill the empty areas.  but with this model, there's no way to pick 
whether it's the solid color or the gradient that does the "backup fill" 
(not without adding another UI element, anyway, which i'm not thrilled 
with).

    -brian



More information about the Xfce4-dev mailing list