[Xfce-bugs] [Bug 16388] Risk to activates first item of right click menu accidentally

[bugzilla-daemon at xfce.org]

https://bugzilla.xfce.org/show_bug.cgi?id=16388

jack_the_pirate <ersrpca001 at hotmail.com> changed:

           What    |Removed                     |Added
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
                URL|                            |INVALID

--- Comment #9 from jack_the_pirate <ersrpca001 at hotmail.com> ---
(In reply to alexxcons from comment #8)
> Thanks alot for the answers !
> 
> (In reply to jack_the_pirate from comment #7)
> > ---------------------------------------------
> > Question
> > "- Does the bug show with default Greybird / Adwaita theme ?"
> > 
> > Answer
> > Greybird: Debian 9 XFCE doesn't have a theme with this name.
> sudo apt-get install greybird-gtk-theme
> .. thats the default xfce theme nowadays (but you dont need to test .. see
> below))

- when you say nowadays, you are not talking about Debian 9, and Debian 9 is
the point!
- in Debian 9, the default theme is Xfce, ok? 
- not Greybird
- Greybird is not even installed by default.
- so, there is a bug!
- and this bug happens in ALL themes and ALL themes icons: Adwaita, etc

- in Debian 10, this also happens with the default Debian 10 theme (Xfce)
- so there is a bug!
- BUT if you change the theme to Adwaita, this does NOT happen
- I have said that above in the wall of text (as you call it)

- also, Debian 10 does NOT display the custom actions on the Desktop, in ALL
themes and ALL theme icons!

Like stated here in the Debian Forum:
http://forums.debian.net/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=143220

Or here, in the Arch Forum:
https://bbs.archlinux.org/viewtopic.php?pid=1807697#p1807697

- I guess that's a bug too, isn't it?

- but I guess that's not a bug worth solving to you, because if everybody uses
the latest version of Debian and XFCE and Thunar, there is no bug!

- wonderful for the millions of users that use LTS releases out there that rely
on XFCE and Thunar!:

- Debian 9 LTS is supported until June-2020
https://wiki.debian.org/LTS

- CentOS 7 is supported until June-2024
https://wiki.centos.org/About/Product

Not to mention all the distros that rely on Debian 9 and CentOS 7!


> > Adwaita: Yes, the exact same thing happens.
> > I also tried with other themes and the same thing happens.
> > Note:
> > In Debian 10 with Thunar 1.8.4 with Adwaita theme and Adwaita icon theme
> > this does NOT happen, as stated above.
> Haha, sorry, I did not get that very important detail :P (that's why I
> prefer short, pregnant information, instead huge walls of text) 
> Somewhere in your first commet you wrote the opposite:
> 
> > Debian 10 XFCE - DOES have the issue
> > Thunar 1.8.4
> > Xfce 4.12
> That's why I thought it is still a bug in the current version.

Read again the wall of text if you want, because I said that's related to the
Xfce theme and NOT Adwaita.
There are two parts:
- Debian 10 XFCE - DOES have the issue
[theme Xfce / icon theme Tango]
- Debian 10 XFCE - does NOT have the issue after changing theme to Adwaita
[theme Adwaita / icon theme Tango]



> I suppose the fix of Bug #14216 as well would fix your problem in Debian 9.
> The fix only was applied to the 1.8.x branch, not to the 1.6.x branch, since
> it was considered to be a regression.
> As said above, thunar 1.6.x will not get any further bugfixes from me.  Even
> if I would push bugfixes to the 1.6.x branch, Debian 9 and CentOS 7 even now
> dont use the latest bugfix version of the thunar 1.6.x branch (which is
> 1.6.18).
> 
> So I think the options you have are:
> - Update your system to Debian10 / Cent OS8, where the bug does not show (I
> would advice so, since you anyhow need to do that sooner or later)

Like I said above, the custom actions don't work in the Desktop on Debian 10!
So that's not an option for people that use a lot of custom actions and also on
the Desktop!



> - Install thunar 1.6.x from source and apply the patch of Bug #14216 to
> check if it helps

What patch? 
I read the post and I didn't see any patch!
I only see your comments saying "it only happens if" 4 times but not solving
anything!


Also, in Google you can find other users complaining about this issue. 

The problem is that everybody call this bug something different, and call the
menu different names:
- right-click menu
- service menu
- custom actions menu
- etc

And may this be solved or not, but the truth is that this is affecting
everybody that uses CentOS 7 (Thunar and Desktop), Debian 10 (in the Desktop)
and Debian 9 (Thunar and Desktop).

And these distros are used by people that do not want bleeding edge distros!
For that, there is Fedora and Ubuntu!

The point of stable LTS distros is for everything work well and like it is
intended for their software versions!

Finally, I've made this bug report for me, but also for the other people of the
XFCE forum, that posted there in the initial post, and asked there for this bug
to be reported!

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.