[Thunar-dev] Bug 6050: thunar-volman shows up in non-XFCE menu

Tanjeff-N. Moos tanjeff at cccmz.de
Sat Feb 28 11:55:27 CET 2015


Hello devs,

some time ago I opened the bug 6050
(https://bugzilla.xfce.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6050) which was discussed
controversially, then closed. Harald Judt asked me to discuss the topic
on the mailing list, so that a wider audience participates the
discussion. I hope that this is the correct list :)


Here is my original request:

  The thunar-volman "Removable Drives and Media" shows up in the GNOME
  settings menu, and possibly in others, too (KDE? LXDE?).

  However, this is a thunar bug: in the
  file /usr/share/applications/thunar-volman-settings.desktop, the line
      OnlyShowIn=XFCE;
  should be added to indicate that this is a XFCE-specific item.


The arguments so far were:
- Why would anyone install thunar-volman without thunar on a DE that
  has a filemanager and very likely a volman too?
  - When multiple users are sharing the same computer, multiple DE
    might be installed. The thunar-settings should not show up in the
    "wrong" DE, then.
- The thunar-setting is named "Removable Drives and Media" in the menu,
  which is very similar to the equivalent GNOME-settings, for example.
  This can be very confusing to users.

So let the discussion begin :-)

Kind regards, Tanjeff


-- 

Ich unterstütze XMPP und OTR: tanjeff at jabber.ccc.de

Mein PGP-key (6298447C):

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG v2.0.22 (GNU/Linux)
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=W7dr
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----


More information about the Thunar-dev mailing list